This past summer, I found myself navigating in gridlocked traffic on the scorching streets of a southern French city. At a crossing, my companion in the front seat suggested a right turn toward a famous spot for fish soup. Yet, the navigation app on my phone commanded us to continue straight. Weary and in a stifling car, I followed the algorithm's advice. Minutes later, we were stranded at a construction site.
A seemingly trivial event, perhaps. But one that encapsulates a central dilemma of our era, where technology touches nearly every facet of existence: whom do we trust to a greater degree – fellow humans and our own intuition, or the algorithm?
The Enlightenment's Promise and Our Modern Relapse
The influential German philosopher Immanuel Kant once defined the Enlightenment as "humanity's emergence from its self-inflicted nonage." This immaturity, he wrote, "is the incapacity to use one's own understanding without guidance from an external source." For ages, that directing force for human thought was often the priest, the king, or the landowner – figures claiming to speak for divine will. To explain phenomena like changing seasons, people sought answers in religion. In organizing the fabric of society, from economics to love, faith served as the primary guide.
“Sapere aude!” or “Have courage to use your reason!”
Kant maintained that humans always possessed the ability to think rationally. They simply lacked the confidence to employ it. With upheavals in America and France, a new dawn emerged: logic would supplant blind faith, and the intellect, liberated from authority, would become the engine of progress and a better world.
Today, two and a half centuries later, one might question if we are slipping back into a form of intellectual immaturity. An app suggesting a driving route is merely the start. AI risks becoming our new "other" – a unseen overseer that steers our decisions and behaviors. We are in danger of relinquishing the hard-won courage to think independently – and now, not to gods or kings, but to computer programs.
The Swift Adoption and Subtle Dangers of Algorithmic Reliance
ChatGPT was launched only in 2022, and yet a recent study found that an overwhelming majority of people had engaged with artificial intelligence in the previous six months. Whether contemplating a breakup or choosing a candidate, individuals are increasingly turning to algorithms for guidance. Research suggests a significant portion of user prompts relate to non-work topics. Even more striking than our reliance on AI for judgment is what happens when we allow it express for us. Composition is now among the top uses for tools like ChatGPT, just behind practical requests. The celebrated American author Joan Didion once remarked, “I write entirely to discover what I am thinking.” What transpires when we stop composing? Do we cease discovering?
Worryingly, emerging research suggests the outcome may be affirmative. A study conducted by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology used electroencephalography to track the mental engagement of essay writers who had access to AI, traditional search engines, or nothing. Those who could rely on AI displayed the lowest brain activity and had trouble quoting their own work. Perhaps most concerning was that after a few months, individuals in the AI group grew progressively lazier, copying large sections of text.
“Laziness and cowardice,” Kant wrote, “are the reasons why so great a proportion of men … remain in perpetual nonage.”
Certainly, AI's appeal stems from its efficiency. It is fast, reduces effort and – importantly – offers a new method to offload responsibility. In his 1941 book, Escape from Freedom, the German psychoanalyst Erich Fromm proposed that the rise of fascism could be understood by a preference to surrender personal freedom in for the sake of the comforting security of obedience. AI offers a modern method of relinquishing the burden of having to decide for oneself.
The Black Box Problem: Faith Over Reason
AI's primary draw is its ability to accomplish things outside human capability – analyzing vast datasets at lightning pace. Stuck in the car in Marseille, this was, ultimately, why I chose to trust the app over my friend (a choice she took as an affront). With access to all the data, surely the algorithm had superior insight – or so I thought.
The core issue is that AI is a opaque system. It produces knowledge, but not always deepening human comprehension. We do not truly know how AI reaches its decisions – including its programmers acknowledge the opacity. Nor can we check its logic against clear, objective criteria. So when we heed AI's advice, we are not being guided by reason. We are back in the domain of faith. In dubio pro machina: when in doubt, trust the machine – that may become our 21st-century guiding principle.
Using Without Losing: The Critical Balance
AI can be a formidable ally for mankind in scientific pursuit. It can help medical research, free us from "bullshit jobs", or handle administrative chores – duties that are repetitive and are unfulfilling. This is beneficial. But Kant and his contemporaries did not champion reason over faith just so humans could assemble better furniture or have extra free time. Critical thinking was not just about efficiency – it was a practice of liberty and human emancipation.
Human thought is inherently messy and error-prone, but it compels us to argue, to doubt, to test ideas – and to recognize the limits of our own understanding. It fosters confidence, both individually and collectively. For Kant, the exercise of reason was never solely about acquiring knowledge; it was about enabling people to become agents of their own destinies, and to oppose control. It was about building a ethical society grounded in the common foundation of rational discourse, rather than blind belief.
With all the undeniable benefits AI brings, the key question is this: how can we harness its promise of advanced capability without undermining human reasoning, the cornerstone of the Enlightenment and of free societies themselves? That is likely one of the defining questions of our century. It is a question we must strive not to outsource to the algorithm.